Why borrow through SMSF?
In the past, SMSF trustees may have found it difficult to consider direct property investments as they may not have had sufficient funds available to buy the property outright.
Similarly, where an SMSF may have had sufficient funds, it would often have resulted in a significant portion of the fund’s assets being invested in direct property which impacted on the fund’s ability to adequately diversify its investments. As such, the ability to borrow through an SMSF can assist the fund to buy direct property, catering for both of these situations.
If you already own business premises, this ability to borrow can also help to facilitate the transfer of these premises into your SMSF should the circumstances permit.
While it is true that SMSF borrowings have predominantly been used to acquire property investments, they can also be used to buy other investments such as shares. By borrowing, a fund increases its ability to buy larger shareholdings which in turn can provide higher levels of overall growth and income – not to mention maximize the benefits associated with franking credits inside an SMSF.
And finally, when you borrow money to purchase an investment in your own name, you will generally receive a tax deduction for any interest you pay on this loan. But you will not receive a tax deduction on principal repayments. Where an SMSF borrows money, it is responsible for making loan repayments. However, in order to make these loan repayments, the fund will use its investment earnings (e.g. rent or dividends), and/or contributions that you make to your fund. So, if you are making fully tax deductible contributions into your fund, either directly or through your business, and these contributions are being used by your fund to make principal and interest loan repayments – the result is similar to receiving a tax deduction for principal loan repayments.
What are the key rules?
While there are a number of important rules and considerations, let’s take a look at some of the more important ones.
Firstly, the asset that your fund purchases with the borrowed money must be a single acquirable asset as defined by superannuation law. This generally means that the borrowed money can only be used to buy one property, or in the context of shares, a parcel of identical shares in the same company (acquired at the same time).
As a result, an SMSF cannot buy several properties under the one borrowing arrangement. Similarly, borrowed money cannot be used to buy a share portfolio investing in shares across different companies – this is part of the reason why borrowing to buy shares through an SMSF has not been popular.
Secondly, where an SMSF has borrowed money to buy an asset, this asset cannot generally be improved upon nor replaced while the loan is still outstanding. This means an SMSF cannot borrow to facilitate a property development. Similarly, because assets cannot be replaced, share investments cannot be actively traded – another reason why borrowing money to buy shares through an SMSF has not been popular.
Thirdly, in order to ensure that borrowing through your SMSF does not place other retirement investments held in your SMSF at risk, the asset that is purchased under a borrowing arrangement must be held in a specific holding trust until the loan is repaid. Further, the only SMSF asset that can be used as security for this loan is the asset that is held within this trust – hence the name Limited Recourse Borrowing Arrangements – which helps to protect other assets held inside your SMSF.
What is a related party borrowing arrangement?
Interestingly, the rules that allow SMSFs to enter into Limited Recourse Borrowing Arrangements also allow for the lender to be anybody you want it to be, provided it is a genuine loan.
So, depending on what circumstances are most appropriate for you and your fund, a loan can be obtained from either a bank or other lending institution, or you, your business, a family member or your own company or trust could provide the loan to your SMSF.
In some cases, you can even consider borrowing money personally and then on-lending that money to your SMSF, allowing a greater degree of flexibility.
Providing a related party loan to your fund, presents an opportunity to quickly get money into your superannuation fund – over and above the contribution caps – to allow your fund to purchase an investment asset.
Also, because it is a loan, as opposed to a contribution, the money lent to your fund will be repaid to you over time – so your money will not be locked in the superannuation system until retirement. This has been an attraction of LRBAs for younger persons who wish to generate profits with the SMSF at low tax rates whilst retaining access to the loan capital.
Of course, as with any transaction your fund enters into the arm’s length requirements must be considered. Generally this requires transactions to be entered into and carried out on commercial terms. Therefore, the terms and conditions of the loan must be carefully considered to not infringe the superannuation laws or attract tax penalties.
Also, any interest you receive from your fund will be taxable. Of course, if you have expenses that you have incurred in providing this loan to your fund, for example interest payable under an on-lending scenario, these expenses will likely be tax deductible – thus offsetting some of the tax.
What else do I need to know?
Should you decide to borrow through your SMSF, an appropriate exit strategy is critical. As part of an exit strategy insurance, such as life and disability cover, can play an integral role in ensuring your fund has the necessary resources to repay outstanding loans should something unexpected occur.
Equally, general insurance is important in protecting the asset itself. For example, if property is destroyed, insurance proceeds can be used to repay any outstanding loan amount, avoiding the likelihood of lenders looking to take action on personal guarantees.
Finally, there are a number of complexities when it comes to matters concerning stamp duty and other taxes that have not been discussed here. To avoid falling into any unpleasant traps, it is important that you seek advice before proceeding to ensure that you follow the right path to success.